Insurance Claims

While we're sorry for your loss, we are also happy to be of service to you at the time when you most need the insurance you purchased from us. You can stop in or call your account manager and she can assist you with filing your claim, or you can contact the company directly. Below is a list of our insurance carriers and their contact numbers. (After office hours, you may want to contact your insurance company directly.)

If you have any questions or concerns regarding your claim, you can reach us by email at insure@mikepreis.com, or by phone at 845-887-4210. We can help guide you through the process and follow up with the company when needed. Here are some additional tools that may assist you during the claim process.

What to do after a car accident

What you need to do after a homeowner loss

Claims Reporting

Aetna Health Inc
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Aflac
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 992-3522
AIG Private Client Group
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (888) 760-9195
Allstate
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claim Phone Numbers:
Claims Number:    (800) 255-7828
Business Owners' Policy:     (800) 359-1000
Life:     (800) 366-3495
American Collectors Insurance
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 360-2277
American Modern Insurance
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 375-2075
AmTrust
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claim Phone Numbers:
Claims Number:    (888) 239-3909
Commercial Auto Claims:     commautoclaimreport@amtrustgroup.com
Commercial Property Claims:     commpropertyclaimreport@amtrustgroup.com
Cyber Liability:     (877) 207-1047
General Liability Claims:     glclaimreport@amtrustgroup.com
Professional and Management Liability Claims
*notice only accepted in writing:     professionalclaims@amtrustgroup.com
Workers' Compensation Claims:     workerscompclaimreport@amtrustgroup.com
Callicoon Co-operative Insurance Company
Go to Website (Claims Page)
CDPHP
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Chubb
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 252-4670
CNA Surety
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (877) 672-6115
Condon and Skelly
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 257-9496
Emergency Services Insurance Program (ESIP)
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Erie and Niagara Insurance Association
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Fire Districts of New York Mutual Insurance Co, Inc.
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Foremost
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 527-3907
GEICO
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 841-3000
Grundy
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (877) 338-4004
Hagerty Insurance
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claim Phone Numbers:
Claims Number: (800) 385-0274
Catlin Boat Claims: (800) 762-2628
J.C. Taylor
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 272-6764
K&K Insurance
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 237-2917
Liberty Mutual Insurance
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (833) 218-0222

Main Street America Insurance
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (877) 425-2467
Markel Insurance Company
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 362-7535
National Flood Insurance (FEMA)
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (877) 336-2627
New York Central Mutual
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (888) 234-6926
New York Municipal Insurance Reciprocal (NYMIR)
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claim Phone Numbers:
Claims Number: (516) 227-2120
Claims Emergencies: (800) 894-9341
New York Schools Insurance Reciprocal (NYSIR)
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 476-9747
New York State Insurance Fund (NYSIF)
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (888) 875-5790
Pennsylvania Lumbermans Mutual Insurance Company
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 752-1895
Philadelphia Insurance Companies
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 765-9749
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 333-7642
Progressive Insurance
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 776-4737
RLI Corp
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 331-4929
Security Mutual Insurance
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Security Mutual Life Insurance Company of New York
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 846-6305
Selective Flood
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (877) 348-0552
ShelterPoint
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Statewide Underwriting Services
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 721-5001 x2
Sterling Insurance Company
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 462-4661
Travelers
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claim Phone Numbers:
Claims Number: (800) 252-4633
Business Insurance Claims: (800) 238-6225
Tuscarora Wayne Insurance Company
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (570) 746-1515
Utica National
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claims Number: (800) 216-1420

Insurance Claims

Claims Reporting

Address: